The verified record

Every number below is computed from public records of closed sales, last 24 months · how we compute this
28
homes closed, last 24 mo
▲ More than 99% of 874 Phelan-area agents
$3.9M
closed sales volume
$67K median sale price
89.5%
of list price achieved on sales
area average 96.0%
33%
of listings needed a price cut
Area average is 31%
Erica Nicolai is a licensed real estate agent (CA DRE #01987192) with KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY in Phelan, CA, with 28 closed transactions verified in public records over the last 24 months at a median sale price of $67,450 and an average 210 days on market on listings (162 days slower than the market median). That is more recent sales in Phelan than 99% of the 874 agents active there.
Source: California public property records. Updated monthly. How we compute these numbers →

About Erica

Compiled from public sources — not written by the agent

Erica Nicolai is a Licensed Realtor with Keller Williams Realty with over 25 years of top-producing sales experience. For 6 years she was a Top Producer in The High Desert Communities for First Team Real Estate, the #1 Independent Brokerage in Southern California. She has closed 63 homes and specializes in residential, new construction, horse and rural properties, and land throughout San Bernardino County, Inland Empire, High Desert, and Los Angeles County.

ResidentialNew constructionHorse and rural propertiesLand Dutch

Performance in detail

Verified from public records · 2023–2026 · metrics shown only where at least 3 closed listings support them

Closed transactions by year

Current year is partial

13 2023 20 2024 10 2025 9 2026

Price range of closed sales

Middle 50% of Erica's transactions vs the Phelan market

$30K $67K $145K mkt $350K
Middle 50% of sale prices; dot = agent median, dashed = market median

Who Erica represents

52 total closed sides, 2023–2026

26 seller-side (50%) 26 buyer-side (50%)
Avg days on market
210
162 days slower than the market median
Active listings now
11
on market today
Closed 2023–2026
52

Where Erica sells

Closed sales by ZIP, last 24 months

92371
Phelan
Sales11
Median price$56K
DOM vs ZIP median136 vs 47
92397
Wrightwood
Sales6
Median price$445K
DOM vs ZIP median202 vs 56
#10 of 12 agents
92372
Pinon Hills
Sales5
Median price$78K
DOM vs ZIP median112 vs 65
ZIPCity Sales (24 mo)Median priceAvg DOM
92301 El Mirage 3 $17K 306
92382 Running Springs 2 $25K
93591 Llano 1 $15K

4 more ZIPs with older sales (before the last 24 months) not shown.

Questions to ask Erica in an interview

Generated from this agent's own public sales record — bring them to your first call

  1. 33% of your listings needed a price cut — how do you set the initial list price?
  2. Your listings average 210 days on market vs the 48-day local median — what's your marketing plan?
  3. Your typical sale is $67K — how does your approach change for a home like mine?
  4. Who will I actually work with day-to-day — you or a team member?

Compare with similar Phelan agents

Ranked by verified sales in public records, last 24 months — no agent pays for placement

AgentSales (24 mo)Median priceAvg DOMSale÷listPrice cuts
Erica Nicolai 28 $67K 210 89.5% 33%
Robert Sheehan 68 $68K 59 96.0% 48%
Jim Suh 9 $69K 344 95.6% 50%
Ruby Perera 3 $65K 49 95.2% 33%
Lizeth Guerra 6 $63K 97 98.2% 60%
Mario Martinez Calva 55 $73K 99 91.6% 61%

Frequently asked questions

How many homes has Erica Nicolai sold?

Erica Nicolai has 52 publicly recorded closed transactions in 2023–2026, including 28 in the last 24 months (26 representing sellers, 26 representing buyers over the full period).

What price range does Erica Nicolai work in?

Erica Nicolai's closed sales have a median price of $67,450; the middle 50% of transactions fall between $30,000 and $145,000.

Is Erica Nicolai's license active?

Erica Nicolai holds an active California DRE license (#01987192). License status can be verified on the California DRE public lookup.

Erica NicolaiKELLER WILLIAMS REALTY · Phelan, CA
Check my fit

Data window 2023–2026, computed 2026-09-05 · Dispute or correct this data · *our public sales record begins 2023; Erica's career may predate it