Top real estate agents in Middletown, CA
Everything you need to choose well in Middletown: what the market is doing, where your home fits, and which of its 54 ranked agents actually deliver — ranked by verified results, never by who paid.
The Middletown market right now
Last 12 months, compared with the 12 before · verified closed salesHow the Middletown market is moving
Median sale price by quarter
Homes sold by quarter
The long view: Middletown home values since 2012
Median sale price by year
Long-term data provided by Redfin, a national real estate brokerage. Current year partial.
Where does your home fit in Middletown?
The middle half of Middletown homes sold between $116K and $515K over the last 24 months — and one in ten topped $715K. Agents who win in one price range are often invisible in another, so compare agents against your price point, not just the citywide average.
Most agents here barely transact — that's why the ranking matters
Half of the 57 agents who closed a deal in Middletown in the last two years closed 2 or fewer. Experience in your market and price range is rare — the list below shows who actually has it.
The Middletown leaderboard
| # | Agent | Brokerage | Score | Sales (24 mo) in Middletown | Median price | Avg DOM | Sale÷list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jennifer Wall | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 73 | 8 | $323K | 74 | 95.6% |
| 2 | Rochelle Costello | Navigate RE Co. | 72 | 7 | $200K | 57 | 91.7% |
| 3 | Kathey Crothers | Navigate Real Estate | 67 | 7 | $333K | 187 | 96.8% |
| 4 | Yvette Sloan | NextHome Yvette Sloan | 65 | 6 | $640K | 161 | 96.2% |
| 5 | Shannon Williams | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 64 | 14 | $243K | 135 | 87.7% |
| 6 | "Pi" Kimberly Stryker | Timothy Toye and Associates | 62 | 4 | $428K | 190 | 100.0% |
| 7 | Mara Eichelmann | Sotheby's International Realty | 60 | 5 | $730K | 290 | 98.6% |
| 8 | Tama Prokopowich | NextHome Experiences | 59 | 3 | $360K | 191 | 100.1% |
| 9 | Bridget King | Luxe Places International Realty | 56 | 16 | $325K | 151 | 83.1% |
| 10 | Erica Bergstrom | Navigate Real Estate | 55 | 2 | $710K | 74 | 97.5% |
| 11 | Petra Bergstrom | Navigate RE Co. | 53 | 2 | $715K | 74 | 96.7% |
| 12 | Cynthia Smith | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 53 | 2 | $457K | 74 | 94.6% |
| 13 | Timothy Toye | Timothy Toye and Associates | 53 | 7 | $108K | 291 | 89.8% |
| 14 | August Schmitt | August Schmitt Realty Solutions | 51 | 5 | $40K | 215 | 88.3% |
| 15 | Jessica Elliott | Luxe Places International Realty | 47 | 5 | $144K | 467 | 71.0% |
| 16 | Robert Willroy | Country Air Properties | 44 | 2 | $80K | 173 | 90.6% |
| 17 | Joi Wright | Navigate Real Estate | 37 | 2 | $215K | 63 | 92.0% |
| 18 | Faylen Silva | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 36 | 1 | $480K | 74 | 95.8% |
| 19 | Candelaria Alanis | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 32 | 4 | $170K | 22 | 84.7% |
| 20 | Lisa Wink | NextHome in the Valley | 28 | 3 | $482K | 119 | 98.7% |
Score (0–100) summarizes each agent's recent verified results in Middletown — sales closed, speed, and pricing outcomes. Agents cannot pay to change it. Showing the top 20 of 54 ranked agents (5+ closed sales here, last 24 months) — browse all 73 agents active in Middletown.
Skip the guesswork
Answer a few questions about your home and plans — we'll narrow Middletown's agents to the handful worth interviewing, using the same performance data on this page.
More Middletown rankings
Who actually sells Middletown
Brokerage share of agent transaction sides, last 24 months.
Frequently asked questions
Who are the top real estate agents in Middletown, CA?
Based on verified sale results over the last 24 months, the top agents in Middletown include Jennifer Wall, Rochelle Costello, Kathey Crothers. Rankings reflect closed sales, speed of sale, and pricing results — agents cannot pay for placement.
How are Middletown agents ranked?
By verified sale results in Middletown: how much an agent actually closes, how fast their listings sell versus the local norm, and how their pricing holds up. No agent can pay to change their position.
Which brokerages sell the most homes in Middletown?
By share of agent transaction sides over the last 24 months: RE/MAX Gold Lake County (24.2%), Luxe Places International Realty (17%), Timothy Toye and Associates (9.8%).
What is the Middletown housing market like in 2026?
Over the last 12 months Middletown recorded 41 home sales at a median $300,000 (+2.6% vs prior year). Homes typically sell in 91 days at 91.2% of asking price, and 37% of listings took a price cut before selling.