Top real estate agents in 95461 (Middletown, CA)
The 95461 market at a glance, and the 62 agents with verified sales here in the last 24 months — ranked by results, never by who paid.
The ZIP 95461 market right now
Last 12 months, compared with the 12 before · verified closed salesHow 95461 is moving
Median sale price by quarter
Homes sold by quarter
Where does your home fit in ZIP 95461?
The middle half of ZIP 95461 homes sold between $85K and $452K over the last 24 months — and one in ten topped $651K. Agents who win in one price range are often invisible in another, so compare agents against your price point, not just the citywide average.
The 95461 leaderboard
| # | Agent | Brokerage | Score | Sales | Median price | Avg DOM | Sale÷list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jennifer Wall | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 78 | 956 | $259K$265K | 6683 | 98.1%96.7% |
| 2 | Rochelle Costello | Navigate RE Co. | 72 | 721 | $200K$255K | 57122 | 91.7%91.4% |
| 3 | Shannon Williams | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 68 | 1657 | $275K$374K | 86104 | 88.0%94.7% |
| 4 | "Pi" Kimberly Stryker | Timothy Toye and Associates | 68 | 1094 | $45K$130K | 183142 | 99.8%87.7% |
| 5 | Cynthia Smith | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 66 | 34 | $434K$350K | 60119 | 95.8%97.4% |
| 6 | Timothy Toye | Timothy Toye and Associates | 65 | 1793 | $113K$111K | 198234 | 94.5%92.3% |
| 7 | Kathey Crothers | Navigate Real Estate | 64 | 712 | $333K$290K | 187137 | 96.8%97.2% |
| 8 | Mara Eichelmann | Sotheby's International Realty | 63 | 545 | $730K$489K | 139109 | 98.6%95.5% |
| 9 | Robert Willroy | Country Air Properties | 62 | 620 | $19K$41K | 88152 | 87.8%94.2% |
| 10 | Yvette Sloan | NextHome Yvette Sloan | 61 | 756 | $566K$340K | 182105 | 93.8%96.9% |
| 11 | Tama Prokopowich | NextHome Experiences | 60 | 332 | $360K$116K | 131166 | 100.1%92.3% |
| 12 | Bridget King | Luxe Places International Realty | 54 | 1656 | $350K$280K | 15188 | 83.1%91.5% |
| 13 | Erica Bergstrom | Navigate Real Estate | 54 | 222 | —$343K | 7462 | 97.5%95.4% |
| 14 | Petra Bergstrom | Navigate RE Co. | 51 | 221 | —$343K | 7455 | 96.7%94.5% |
| 15 | August Schmitt | August Schmitt Realty Solutions | 51 | 5177 | $40K$122K | 172141 | 88.3%91.7% |
| 16 | Faylen Silva | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 50 | 282 | —$370K | 101151 | 96.8%97.9% |
| 17 | Jessica Elliott | Luxe Places International Realty | 50 | 632 | $95K$144K | 281247 | 78.9%78.0% |
| 18 | Tiffany Peng | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 47 | 159 | —$260K | 1788 | 98.6%92.9% |
| 19 | Trung Nguyen | RE/MAX Gold Lake County | 47 | 154 | —$238K | 1788 | 98.6%92.9% |
| 20 | Damon Schoeffler | Timothy Toye and Associates | 47 | 426 | $88K$112K | 277106 | 90.9%91.0% |
All figures reflect closed sales from the last 24 months in public records. “—” means fewer than 3 recorded sales in this area; switch to “All areas” for the agent’s full record.
Score (0–100) summarizes each agent's recent verified results in this ZIP. Agents cannot pay to change it.
Skip the guesswork
Answer a few questions about your home and plans — we'll narrow Middletown's agents to the handful worth interviewing, using the same performance data on this page.
More 95461 rankings
Frequently asked questions
Who are the top real estate agents in 95461?
Based on verified closed sales in ZIP 95461 (Middletown, CA) over the last 24 months, top agents include Jennifer Wall, Rochelle Costello, Shannon Williams. No agent pays for placement.
What is the 95461 housing market like?
Over the last 24 months, ZIP 95461 recorded 103 home sales at a median $275,000 and a median 80 days on market.